Being Different: An Indian Challenge to Western Universalism

By Rajiv Malhotra

India is greater than a country kingdom. it's also a different civilization with philosophies and cosmologies which are markedly certain from the dominant tradition of our occasions - the West. India's religious traditions spring from dharma which has no detailed identical in Western frameworks. regrettably, within the rush to have fun the transforming into approval for India at the international level, its civilizational matrix is being co-opted into Western universalism, thereby diluting its uniqueness and strength. In Being diverse: An Indian problem to Western Universalism, philosopher and thinker Rajiv Malhotra addresses the problem of a right away and sincere engagement on alterations, through reversing the gaze, repositioning India from being the saw to the observer and looking out on the West from the dharmic viewpoint. In doing so, he demanding situations many hitherto unexamined ideals that either side carry approximately themselves and every different. He highlights that whereas targeted ancient revelations are the root for Western religions, dharma emphasizes self-realization within the physique the following and now. He additionally issues out the critical harmony that underpins dharma's metaphysics and contrasts this with Western proposal and background as an artificial cohesion.
Erudite and interesting, Being diversified opinions stylish reductive translations and analyses the West's nervousness over distinction and fixation for order which distinction the artistic position of chaos in dharma. It concludes with a rebuttal of Western claims of universalism, whereas recommending a multi-cultural worldview.

Show description

Preview of Being Different: An Indian Challenge to Western Universalism PDF

Similar Buddhism books

The Heart of the World: A Journey to Tibet's Lost Paradise

The parable of Shangri-la originates in Tibetan Buddhist ideals in beyul, or hidden lands, sacred sanctuaries that demonstrate themselves to religious pilgrims and in instances of drawback. The extra distant and inaccessible the beyul, the vaster its reputed features. historical Tibetan prophecies claim that the best of all hidden lands lies on the middle of the forbidding Tsangpo Gorge, deep within the Himalayas and veiled through a mammoth waterfall.

The Chan Whip Anthology: A Companion to Zen Practice

Jeffrey L. Broughton deals an annotated translation of the Whip for Spurring scholars Onward during the Chan Barrier Checkpoints (Changuan cejin), which he abbreviates to Chan Whip. This anthology, compiled by means of Yunqi Zhuhong (1535-1615), has served as a Chan guide in either China and Japan considering that its e-book in 1600.

The Zen Canon: Understanding the Classic Texts

Bodhidharma, its first patriarch, apparently acknowledged that Zen Buddhism represents "a detailed transmission outdoors the teaching/Without reliance on phrases and letters. " This asserting, besides the customarily complicated use of language (and silence) through Zen masters, gave upward thrust to the proposal that Zen is a "lived religion," dependent strictly on non-linguistic perform and missing a considerable canon of sacred texts.

Awareness: The Perils and Opportunities of Reality

"This is your warning sign! you could now not have even discovered you have been sleep-walking. such a lot people are more often than not. know-how is an eye-opener. it is Anthony de Mello telling you lightly yet firmly, 'It's time to wake up now. '" --Charles Osgood of "CBS Sunday Morning" and "The Osgood File""Awareness stands out as the serious try of yankee company within the subsequent decade.

Extra info for Being Different: An Indian Challenge to Western Universalism

Show sample text content

As soon as the spirit is effectively imprisoned and chained up in these items, a few emotional fervor or even a certain quantity of mystic looking will be tolerated – inside rational limits; yet, in the end, it truly is probably most secure to do with out those harmful spices. three As Lloyd and Susan Rudolph, students of South Asia on the collage of Chicago, indicate, 'India obvious as a replicate picture of the West seems to be otherworldly, fatalistic, non-egalitarian. it's as if we might be much less ourselves, much less this-worldly, masterful, egalitarian and individualistic if Indians have been much less what they're. '4 Andrew Rotter, an American historian at Colgate college, makes the same element: 'American selves, working mostly in the different types of sexuality, race, and affliction, projected onto Indian Others qualities that appeared loathsome or illicit: Indians have been, between different issues, unsanitary, disorderly, promiscuous, and primitive. '5 presently after India's independence, one other American, Harold Isaacs, interviewed different American teachers, diplomats, politicians, missionaries, enterprise humans, individuals of the media and others to elicit their innovations at the Indians and the chinese language. 6 In describing India, the american citizens he interviewed used such unflattering epithets as 'teeming millions', 'teeming cities', 'swarming masses', 'mobs of people', 'hordes', etc. one of many respondents quite often remarked that India had 'millions of individuals; no one is aware what percentage there are in this human anthill'. 7 american citizens linked powerful smells in India with primitivism and 'filth, dust and disease'. A publication by way of Katherine Mayo, The Face of mom India, grew to become immensely influential in shaping American rules approximately India, and via the mid-1950s it had passed through twenty-seven American versions and offered good over 1 / 4 of 1000000 copies within the usa on my own. Mayo tremendously trendy Muslims for his or her combating spirit to increase their religion, and accordingly she particularly glorified Mahmoud of Ghazni for his violent plunders of India. She in comparison Ghazni to biblical figures similar to Joshua, Gideon and David, simply because he used to be prepared 'to throw away existence itself for the respect of the only God …' It used to be a awful indictment of Hinduism, giving gory information about the abuse of women and ladies, baby brides, nutrients deprivation, sati, and so on. eight whereas a few praised the knowledge and devotion of Hindus, so much reiterated Katherine Mayo's stereotypes to finish that Hinduism used to be 'a debased, hopeless type of religion', generating 'mobs of fans hurling themselves into the Ganges', 'naked ascetics and scrawny fakirs on nails', and 'stupid taboos' – altogether 'a complex, alien mess'. Gandhi known as Mayo's booklet 'a drain inspector's record' and released a scathing feedback of it. in addition, Isaacs is going on, 'the obvious sexual hazard from India used to be [based on] … a deadly eroticism concerning the position: there have been "obscene" sculptures on Hindu temples, phallic symbols in all places, and allegedly rapacious temple monks who have been stated to maintain prostitutes contained in the partitions for his or her personal fell pleasures'.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.24 of 5 – based on 47 votes